We ran the numbers, and here are our Top 125 Games for 2017. These are on a per-unit basis, and includes all sales throughout the year. Plus, we factored out a few things like used games, puzzles, and individual packs of collectible games such as Magic and Destiny. The top spot goes to Kingdomino! A well-deserved victory.

Here is our list, in order of units sold:

1 Kingdomino
2 Codenames
3 Sushi Go!
4 Patchwork
5 Sushi Go! Party
6 Pandemic 2nd Edition
7 Sleeping Queens
8 Forbidden Island
9 Dice Forge
10 Dragonwood
11 Ticket to Ride
12 Mysterium
13 Codenames Duet
14 Catan 5th ed
15 Photosynthesis
16 Exit The Abandoned Cabin
17 Tenzi
18 Harry Potter Hogwarts Bttl DB
19 Jaipur
20 L5R LCG Core Set
21 Arkham LCG Core Set
22 Fuse
23 Century Spice Road
24 D&D5 Player’s Handbook
25 Exploding Kittens
26 Hanabi
27 Roll Player
28 Terraforming Mars
29 Codenames Pictures
30 7 Wonders Duel
31 Exit The Secret Lab
32 Love Letter
33 D&D5 Xanathar’s Guide Alt Art
34 Splendor
35 Rhino Hero
36 D&D5 Starter Set
37 Cards Against Humanity Base
38 Flip Ships
39 Dancing Eggs
40 Exit The Pharaoh’s Tomb
41 Ticket to Ride Europe
42 Rhino Hero Super Battle
43 Clank!
44 Spot It Boxed
45 Hero Realms
46 Dixit
47 Bang! The Dice Game
48 Happy Salmon
49 Scythe
50 D&D5 Monster Manual
51 D&D5 Xanathar’s Guide
52 Unlock The Formula
53 Harry Potter Hogwarts Monsters
54 Bananagrams
55 Wits & Wagers Deluxe
56 Ice Cool
57 Mansions Beyond the Threshold
58 Say Anything
59 Catan 5th ed 5-6 Player Ext
60 Charterstone
61 Terraforming Mars Hellas Ellys
62 Carcassonne
63 Codenames Disney
64 Tsuro
65 Unlock The House on the Hill
66 Magic Maze
67 Snake Oil
68 Pandemic Legacy S2 Yellow*
69 Sherlock Consulting Jack the Ripper
70 Word A Round
71 Pandemic Legacy S2 Black*
72 Fallout The Board Game
73 Imploding Kittens
74 Fox in the Forest
75 D&D5 Tales From Yawning Portal
76 Queendomino
77 Labyrinth (Ravensburger)
78 Scythe Wind Gambit
79 Castle Panic
80 Lords of Waterdeep
81 Rat a Tat Cat
82 Exploding Kittens NSFW
83 Dominion 2nd Ed
84 Lost Cities Card Game
85 Betrayal at Baldur’s Gate
86 Scythe Invaiders From Afar
87 Forbidden Desert
88 Guillotine
89 Bohnanza
90 Twilight Imperium 4
91 D&D5 DM Screen Reincarnated
92 Kittens in a Blender
93 Unlock Squeek & Sausage
94 Splendor Cities
95 Betrayal at House o/t Hill
96 Star Wars Rebellion Rise Empire
97 D&D5 Character Sheets
98 Starfinder Core Rulebook
99 Gear Cube
100 Anomia
101 Fluxx 5.0
102 Ex Libris
103 Telestrations
104 Exit The Polar Station
105 D&D5 Dungeon Masters Guide
106 Mysterium Secrets & Lies
107 Unlock The Nautilus Trap
108 King of Tokyo 2nd Ed
109 Camel Up
110 Coup
111 Exit The Forbidden Castle
112 Ticket to Ride USA 1910 Exp
113 Mansions of Madness 2nd Core
114 Clank! Sunken Treasures
115 Dutch Blitz
116 Scythe Game Board Extension
117 Exit The Forgotten Island
118 Azul
119 Unearth
120 Flatline
121 Mint Works
122 D&D5 Volo’s Guide to Monsters
123 Orchard Memo Game
124 7 Wonders
125 7 Wonders Duel Pantheon

*If you combine sales of both Black and Yellow boxes (they are the same inside), Pandemic Legacy Season 2 comes in at 18th place.